|
List of Abstracts
(In alphabetical order)
Dr. Barbara Baert (University of Leuven, Belgium)
Helena in Andria (Apulia, early 15th. Century). The Discovery
of the True Cross between East and West
In the absys of the crypt of the Holy Cross Church in
Andria (Apulia) four mural paintings are preserved with the story of
Helena finding the True Cross: The arrival of Helena, Judas Cyriacus
in the dry well, the Discovery and the Testing of the cross and finally
the veneration of the erected cross. Little attention is made to this
early fiftheenth century cycle (only: B. MOLAJOLI, La crypta di S. Croce
in Andria, in Atti e memoria della società Magna Grecia. Bizantina-Medievale,
1, 1934, p. 25-35, p. 32, fig. 2.)
In this paper I want to examine:
1. The iconographical tradition of the murals in the context of the
diffusion of the theme in the Italo-Byzantine south of Italy. In fact,
this research can be an important counterpart to the always considered
Tuscan monopoly of the theme during the fifteenth century (the so-called
Firenze-Volterra,-Empoli-Arezzo cluster).
2. The appearance of the theme in connection with possible influences
and impulses from the Balcan/Slavic aerea. These exchanges of the Helena-material
between East and West during the later Middle Ages are underestimated
in the research.
3. And finally, I will contextualise the Helena cycle in the context
of the so-called cave-churches of Andria, which are related to the monastic-hermit-culture
in Apulia.
Jens Baumgarten (University of Campinas, Brazil)
Italian Artists and Saints in Portuguese America: The Transformations
of Post-Tridentine Concepts
This paper will examine various aspects of the migration,
especially of Italian artistic and religious concepts, to the Portuguese
America in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. In this context
it will be necessary to analyze the Catholic theory of visualization
as well, focusing on different methods used to transform this visual
system within the context of several colonial societies in the Americas.
Emphasis will be placed on societies (particularly those in Brazil),
with largely indigenous and/or African heritages, which possess their
own visual systems that ostensibly highlight “idolic” images.
The complex effects of these transformative processes lead to an analysis
of the relationship between “internal” and “external”
images, and also between image and word. This paper will present the
ways in which word and image may be mutually translated,while also attempting
to challenge the bipolar paradigm of a clearly marked opposition between
the colonial and the “indigenous” gaze.
Dr. Nirit Ben-Aryeh Debby (Ben Gurion University of the Negev,
Israel)
Images of the Saracens in Italian Renaissance Art
This paper focuses on the encounter between the Christian
and the Islamic worlds as it appears in Florentine churches. It explores
images of the Muslims connected to the ideas of mission, conversion
and crusade. Crusading sympathy in Tuscany, particularly in Florence,
had a long history, going back to the twelfth century. The role of the
mendicant orders, established in the great convents of Santa Croce and
Santa Maria Novella, was crucial in winning sympathy for the crusades.
This tradition continued in the fifteenth century, when Florence openly
voiced support for papal crusading efforts and Franciscan and Dominican
preachers continued a tradition of mendicant crusade sermons. The mendicant
movements developed special types of artworks, either paintings or sculptures
in order to disseminate their religious ideals. The images discussed
would include works by Giotto, Agnolo Gaddi, Taddeo Gaddi, Benedetto
da Maiano from Santa Croce; Andrea da Firenze, Andrea Orcagna, Paolo
Uccello, Domenicho Ghirlandaio from Santa Maria Novella.
Prof. Andreas Beyer (University of Basel, Switzerland)
Mount Vesuvius and Southern Italy: Artistic, Literary and
Scientific Perception Around 1800
The talk will focus on the literary (Wilhelm Heinse, Johann
Wolfgang Goethe,Karl Philipp Moritz), artistic (Jakob Philipp Hackert,
Joseph Wright of derby, Pietro Fabris) and scientific (Sir William Hamilton)
perception of the 'natural theatre' of Mount Vesuvius and the landscape
of Southern Italy. Never before (and not afterwards) had Naples and
the Kingdom of Southern Italy become the focus of artistic and scientific
interests in such an intense way as around 1800.
The talk will try to show, how the different ways of perception, understanding
and interpretation of this particular scenery interact, correspond and
differ, thus also illustrating the specific conditions of the different
genres."
Dr. Simona Cohen (Tel-Aviv University, Israel)
Sculpture in Gandhara – The Meeting of Hellenistic
and Roman Art with the Sculpture of Northern India
Background
The meeting of the art in north-western India with Hellenistic art commenced
with the followers of Alexander the Great, who founded an independent
Greek kingdom in Bactria (presently Afghanistan) in the mid 3rd century
B.C.. Their language was Greek and they preserved the religion, ritual
and art of Greece. Beside the use of local materials it appears that
their absorption of local traditions was minimal.
Western classical influence continued even after the fall of the Hellenistic
kingdom in Bactria and the ascendance of the Kushana rulers , who infiltrated
form north-eastern Asia in the 2nd century B.C.. Their art was exceptional
for its syncretism, expressed, for example, in the combined depictions
of the Greco-Roman pantheon, the Indian and Persian gods, and later
on the image of the Buddha, on imperial coins. Under Kushana rule the
local school of sculpture in the north-western area, called Gandhara,
reached its ultimate achievements (2nd -5th c.). In Gandhara, which
meanwhile became an important center of Buddhism, the earliest images
of the Buddha were depicted under the influence of Greek and Roman models.
The transition from aniconic to iconic depictions of the Buddha, appearing
for the first time since his death in the 6th century B.C., took place
simultaneously in Gandhara and in the sacred city of Mathura, where
his image was depicted in an entirely different style following earlier
Indian stereotypes.
Mercantile land routes between the Roman Empire and China passed through
this area by way of Himalayan passages. Archeological findings indicate
that Roman art objects already reached Gandhara in the 1st century,
some of them presumably on their way eastward. Indian art objects, primarily
of ivory and bone, were transported on the same routes to the Mediterranean
basin.
Formal and Iconographic Analysis
The analysis will emphasize the unique synthesis formed by the Gandharan
school of sculpture between Greco-Roman and local Indian traditions,
in both style and iconography. Examples will include motifs of Greek
mythology in relief and sculpture, Buddhist depictions, such as narratives
of the Buddha's life and sculptured images of the Buddha and Bodhisattvas,
as well as Hindu themes.
Dr. Andreina Contessa (The Hebrew University of Jerusalem,
Israel)
Art and Science in Medieval Catalonia: Ripoll Abbey and
the Transmission of Culture.
Since the Carolingian period and the time of the Middle
Ages, Catalunian scriptoria played a leading role in the transmission
of Classical, Mediterranean and Eastern scientific knowledge to Europe.
A tradition of scientific and astronomical studies flourished in the
Ripoll monastery between the 10th and 12th centuries, as attested by
documentary data and a few existing codices. These manuscripts testify
to the state of scientific knowledge and learning at that time in the
Marca Hispanica and its role in the transmission of culture from Al-Andalus
to Europe, including ancient classical works translated from Arabic
into Latin, not then available in France and Italy.
The miniatures in these codices are very interesting in that they remake
illustrations related to different ancient traditions, reinterpreting,
actualizing and adapting them to the local political and cultural context.
Dr. Adi Erlich, (University of Haifa, Israel)
Who is who: the Ambiguous Iconography in the Art of Hellenistic
Maresha
The ancient city of Maresha, situated in the Judean hills,
used to be a major town in the region of Idumea during the Hellenistic
period. Excavations at the site have yielded rich finds, reflecting
a prosperous eastern Hellenistic city from the 3rd to 2nd centuries
BCE. The artistic finds consist of terracottas, sculptures in stone,
bronzes and wall paintings, which perform a provincial art associated
with the Hellenistic koine, nonetheless having major local features.
Most of the finds are domestic in character, whether coming from residences
or from the numerous subterranean complexes quarried underneath them.
The Hellenistic period at Maresha brought together two cultures: the
Greek culture with its well-defined and figurative visual system of
deities, heroes, mortals and narratives, and a local culture with an
ambiguous and variable iconography, which routed in the Levant for thousands
of years. This syncretism causes uncertainties in the identification
of the embodied figures. The most essential problem is regarding to
deities and related figures which are thought to be syncretistic entities
such as Heracles-Melqart or Aphrodite-Astarte, but also other depictions
confused modern scholars with their indecisive identification, meaning
and function. Besides the question how ancient people interpreted those
visual symbols, we may wonder how they incorporated the unfamiliar Greek
iconographical method into their old-new pantheon and ideas. As two
different attitudes met together, which one took over in terms of iconography,
title and substance? The town of Maresha, which existed continuously
from the Persian to the Hellenistic period, can serve as a case study
for these questions, having numerous iconographical finds in diverse
mediums, and being an Eastern – Hellenistic city under Ptolemaic
– Seleucid rule.
Dr. Anat Falbel (University of Sao Paulo, Brazil)
From Mediterranean to Atlantic: two synagogues in Brazil
The proposition of this text is analyzing the influence
of Mediterranean motives and forms, in the construction of a modern
Jewish architectural identity between the 20 and 30. The idea of a Jewish
Modern Architectural Language rooted in Mediterranean motives and forms
had been a subject of speculation between Jewish theoreticians and architects
involved in the cultural Jewish renaissance as had been envisioned by
Ahad Haam (1856-1927(for whom Erez Israel was the only possible source
for this cultural Renaissance, as well as Martin Buber (1878-1965) who
along with E. M. Lilien and B. Feiwel was the editor of the Juedischer
Verlag (1902), one of the most effective means of invigorating and spreading
the concept of Jewish culture. The German architect Erich Mendelsohn
(1887-1953) was very much influenced by Buber's work - regarding the
Bible as an expression of a reality which enclose the totality of life,
and the idea of revelation when any natural event may be revelation
for him who understands the event as really addressing him and is able
to read its meaning for his personal life".
In addition, Buber and Mendelsohn were both concerned with the confronts
of Jewish and Arab natives in Palestina, believing that the two people
should lived together in a common country, reunited in a future common
destiny. Mendelsohn had tried to develop and East -West vocabulary synthesis
based on a dialogue between western developments and Arab culture and
architecture through the study of the genius loci, justified in his
text Palestine and the World of Tomorrow (1940), in which he considered
the Temple as the synthesis of Mediterranean Culture, this last one
understood as the intermediary of the world interests in the field of
creativity, art and religion.
In fact, the idea of an architectural identity based on Mediterranean
motives can be traced years before when a friend of Mendelsohn, the
American historian and journalist Lewis Mumford (1895-1990) formulated
what could be called a Jewish Modern Architectural Language, publishing
in June, 1925, an article in the American Menorah Journal called "Towards
a Modern Synagogue Architecture". Besides stressing the importance
of the synagogue building in expressing the aspect of unity in the Jewish
Philosophy and the notion of moral and physical cosmos, in this text
Mumford justifies the use of Mediterranean forms, or the Byzantine style,
as he called, because of his permanence for more than fifteen centuries
in Palestine, coming from Egypt, to Asia Minor, lending his vocabulary
to the new Christian communities from the IV to VII century and afterwards
turning Muslim and being still alive in the little Arab villages with
their cubic masses and domes. The problem is that although he surely
intended to contribute to a modern synagogue architecture, we cannot
be sure about his intentions in extending his speculation towards a
Jewish Modern Architectural Language as a nationalist ideology reflection
as was Mendelsohn case, since he seems the inheritor of a Christian
intellectual lineage, traced since the Illustration, which believe in
the role fulfilled by the Jews in spreading the monotheistic idea and
their humanistic contribution to the European culture and civilization
.
The analysis of Mumford's statements lead us to another character in
this chain of set engagements - the biologist, who pioneered a sociological
approach to the study of urbanization, Sir Patrick Geddes (1854-1932),
for whom the term culture encompassed his entire philosophical approach,
and who understood quality of life as an interaction between spatial
form and culture of people . Geddes thought and personality influenced
Mumford's philosophy and writing. The two men maintained a fruitful
correspondence since 1917 till Geddes's death in 1932. When designing
the Hebrew University in Mont Scopus Geddes also returned to the Mediterranean
forms, presenting his project to the Zionist Commission as the "version
of Revelation
XXI-2 .well named as greatest of world outlooks - both historic westwards,
& cosmic eastwards." Alluding to the biblical quotation, Geddes
cleverly made use of the Jewish tradition concept of the Heavenly Jerusalem
that turned into the Earthly to fulfill the nationalistic project.
The acceptance and use of the Mediterranean vocabulary of forms in Eretz
Israel by the British architects and engineers can be understood as
the result of the archeological discoveries of the ends of the XIX and
beginnings of the XX centuries which confirmed the truthfulness of the
Bible. At the same time, they were also testimonies of the Orient that
could relate the present with a Biblical past, the purpose behind the
settlement of the first English churches since the beginnings of the
XIX century associated also with the Jewish conversion that would induced
redemption and the establishment of Israel Kingdom.
The fact is that from Palestine this vocabulary spread between the 1920s
and 1930s all around the world used in Synagogues and Jewish Institutional
buildings. As an example, we would like to show a Brazilian Synagogue
projected in 1928 that can be inserted in the movement of search for
a national language in the arts and architecture between the two world
wars.
Because of its masses volumes, lateral façades with narrow arched
windows and Byzantine domes the Beth El Synagogue partakes Mumford 's
definition of Byzantine style, or the oriental Arab Romantism - the
neo Byzantine style as was defined by Kroyanker , in relation to the
Hurva Synagogue (1864) and the Tifereth Israel (1876), and also to the
Geddes and Mear's project for the Hebrew University (1919) and the Jerusalem
Library (1926), and Austin Harrison's Museum Rockfeller (1929-1935)
project . More than partaking Mumford's idea for a Modern Synagogue
Architecture, the Beth-El building maintained a close dialogue with
the Temple Tifereth Israel, built in Cleveland in 1924.
In November 1925, the Architectural Forum published an article by Richard
Stanwood, about the newly built Temple Tifereth Israel in Cleveland,
a project by Charles Greco, an architect who had built some other synagogues
in the USA. In this article, the author after constructive and architectural
descriptions, justified the formal choice as a consensus between the
architect and the community deciding that the building should not use
the usual styles, but the basic forms existing in those regions where
the Jewish race had passed the period of its national existence. To
achieve this result the architect used an harmonic assemblage of different
motifs that present themselves"...not so oriental...and more Byzantine
than anything else...", expressing the religious spirit and the
essential unity of the Jewish faith.
An explanation that seems very much influenced used by Mumford's formulation
in his "Towards a Modern Synagogue Architecture".
Therefore, we can perceive a true dialogue between the two texts, also
remembering that Mumford used as examples the Temple Emanu-El of San
Francisco, the Temple Euclid Avenue in Cleveland from 1912, and the
Temple Tifereth Israel projected by Charles Greco.
In fact, we believe that Mumford's article was a result of a provocation
made by his friend and mentor Geddes, who in a furious letter dated
some months earlier (April/25) wrote to him about the project for the
Yeshiva of America in New York, published in the B'nai Brith Magazine
(National Jewish Monthly), in March, 1925, as representing the "style
used in the ancient Palestine and following the Salomon Temple".
Geddes suggested to Mumford to write some words to alert the public
and his Jewish friends showing the way for a better project also asking
if there weren't better architects than the ones responsible for the
Ieshiva project. The first suggestion was immediately accepted by Mumford
who wrote his article about the Synagogues, and as for the question,
he answered that the Jewish nepotism was the responsible for those atrocities.
So we close the chain of architectural dialogues with the Temple Beth
El in Sao Paulo inserted in the new modern movement of recuperation
and reevaluation of the national languages between the wars, when Eretz
Israel already recognized as the National Jewish Home was a concrete
reference for their search.
Dr.
Sabina Fulloni (Italian Agency for Enviroment Protection, Italy)
The Mediterranean Basin as vehicle for the
proliferation and continuity of Roman architectural and construction technology
during the antiquity
During the second half of the I. century AD the Roman knowledge
of architecture and construction reached a level of technological sophistication
that allowed the development of plans with solutions of extreme complexity.
This establishment of standards eventually reached its peak during the
second half of the III. century AD. Through the conquest of its provinces,
Rome, therefore, did not only export its own culture to remote countries
, but also its architectural know-how and structural technology, which
eventually would be assimilated by the local people throughout the Mediterranean
Basin. Starting from this common denominator and combined with the own
knowledge, these people used ideas and material in order to create new
constructional typologies that will outlast the fall of the Roman Empire.
These cultures will eventually reinvent the technological accomplishments
of the antiquity, using them for new scopes and incorporating different
functionalities as the occasions may require. Building volumes, shapes
and stylistic elements, in cohesion with the local peculiarities will
create new concepts of architectural expressions, establishing the basis
for the immense and very articulated patrimony of the Western world. Through
the description of impressive examples and some specific details it will
be attempted to illustrate this complex adaptive process that has basically
influenced the development of the mentality and environment of the cultures
around the Mediterranean Basin.
Dr. Anat Gilboa (Northern Baroque Art Queen's University Kingston,
Canada )
The Influence of Plato's Greater Hippias on Rubens's Venus
Frigida
I will consider the influence of Plato's dialogue on Peter
Paul Rubens's 1614 painting Venus Frigida. This study is significant
because the association between Plato's writings and Rubens's painting
has not yet been considered.
In Rubens's painting the nude Venus is crouching near Amor in a defensive
expression. In front of them a Satyr is holding the Horn of Plenty and
fruits symbolizing Ceres and Bacchus. The comic figure of the Satyr,
provocatively stretching his tongue out against the freezing Venus,
denies her from the goods he is holding. In Renaissance and Baroque
art this scene illustrated the phrase 'Without Ceres and Bacchus, Venus
herself becomes lifeless and frigid,' mostly presenting a joyful Venus
in the company of Ceres and Bacchus; the proverb meant to illuminate
human moderation in sensual pleasures.
Rubens's Venus and the Satyr share similarities with the figures in
Andrea Alciato's emblem: 'Adversus naturam peccantes' (Those sinning
against nature). In this emblem a nude woman is shown relieving her
bowels in a vessel meant to hold food. In front of her there is a sculpture
of Satyr. The emblem's motto and image are complemented by a literary
explanation declaring that, 'It is certainly shocking as a deed, but
also a thing wicked to relate, if anyone were to empty the burden of
his bowels in a choenix […]' The choenix was a vessel used to
measure out daily portions of grain in ancient Greece. In Alciato's
poem the vessel is utilized as a reminder to avoid what was believed
to be human idleness. Alciato's image of the crouching figure and the
satyr near her are icons censuring human behavior when it exceeds certain
limits.
These images of Venus Frigida share similarities, exploring the dichotomy
between aestheticism and moralism. However, I will argue that Rubens's
Venus illuminates a contradictory conclusion to the moral teaching of
Alciato's emblem. Rubens's Venus expresses despair because her needs
are not met. This idea is not found in pictorial tradition before the
Baroque but in Plato's work. I will conclude that in this painting Rubens
expresses a unique understanding of classical philosophy. Plato's Greater
Hippias was written as a dialogue between Socrates and Hippias where
Plato assigns his own pragmatic attitude to Socrates concluding that
the Beautiful is beneficial to human life as pleasure and therefore
it (Pleasure/the Beautiful) must not be ignored.
Dr. Gabi Guarino (University of Haifa, Israel)
‘See Naples and Die’: Funeral Imprese in the
Neapolitan Obsequies for the Spanish Habsburgs
Recent research has shown the extensive state sponsorship
of imprese in early modern times functioning as effective conveyors
of political messages. This paper will emphasize their usage in a particular
historical situation neglected so far: the obsequies of Spanish monarchs
in Naples during the seventeenth century. The paper will address two
principal issues. The first concerns the comparative perspective between
center and periphery. The question raised is if there were significant
differences between the funerary imprese representing Habsburg monarchs
in Naples from those in Madrid. Next, the paper will map gender differences
present in the exemplary imprese of deceased queens and kings, trying
to compare how close were Spanish and Neapolitan ideals of sex roles.
In sum, this paper highlights a neglected case study of the Habsburgs'
imagery of power, already acknowledged in their other possessions throughout
Europe and the New World, which vindicates Naples' importance within
Spanish civilization.
Lihi Habas (The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel)
The Art of Imported Marble Chancel Screens and its Influence
on Local Production in the Churches of Provincia Arabia and Palaestina
Tertia: a Case Study
The churches of the Byzantine period within the frontiers
of the provinces of Arabia and Palaestina Tertia were richly decorated
by chancel screens that enclosed the liturgical space. The marble screens
originated in the imperial quarries of Proconnesus whence they were
transported by sea to various locales throughout the Mediterranean basin.
The panels of the screens were decorated in relief with distinctive
motifs bearing deep iconographic and theological significance which
express the main tenets of the Christian faith: belief in the Messiah,
victory over death and the promise of redemption to believers. Most
of the decorations represent an identical idea to that expressed in
the celebration of the Eucharist on the altar beyond the chancel screen.
Yiska Harani (Israel)
Great Saturday’s Holy Fire: Hellenic (and Other) Identities
The twain – liturgy and pilgrimage – often
meet. Not infrequently the end or even the climax of a pilgrimage is
a liturgical event or performance and, conversely, the latter may motivate
the former.
Such is the case of the ceremony of the Holy Fire, which takes place
in the Church of the Anastasis in Jerusalem on Great Saturday. The rite,
which is attested for the first time in the ninth century, is peculiar
to the Eastern churches. It takes place not at midnight, but at noon,
in the light of day. There is no entry of the Easter candle, accompanied
by the thrice repeated Lumen Christi, into the dark church (as in the
Latin rite) but a very concrete, nonmetaphorical emerging of Hagion
Phos (divine light) from the tomb of Christ, which is distributed to
the throngs of congregants and pilgrims.
The role of the ceremony in the structure of the power-play of hierarchical
relations (of the Eastern Churches and their heads, Muslim rulers and
their Christian dhimmis – protected people, etc.) is indirectly
attested to in the accounts of medieval and later pilgrims. However,
as we move into the modern period, the traditional rite becomes the
scenery of contemporary realities, shaping not only individual religious
experience but also the social and communal identities of its eastern
protagonists, namely the Greek, Armenian, Arab and other denominations.
Dr. Avital Heyman (Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Israel)
Mediterranean Sirens Crossing the Mountains of Auvergne-Velay
Migrating from Greek mythology to scripture and ecclesiastical
writing, sirens are best known for the perils they put on the road of
Odysseus, and conversely, on that of the crucified Christ and on that
of the pilgrim, two significations that Odysseus, the eternal voyageur
tied to the mast, came to symbolize in the Middle Ages.
Long acknowledged in past scholarship, the siren motif was perceived
of as a multilayered image whose negative Homeric connotations suited
an even vaster range of destructive meanings, moral, social and political.
More than sheer misogyny the hybrid sirens represent violation of social
order, mainly that of the manly world. It is therefore no coincidence
to find them dwelling in the biblical debauched town of Babylon, and
in the land of Edom, destined to be destroyed, alongside hybrid centaurs,
both in the Septuagint and in the Vulgate. These beasts gained much
popularity throughout the Middle Ages, and embody the ultimate significance
of evil in the medieval bestiary, as well as in wide-ranging exegetical
literature.
This development may stand for the immense dispersion of the siren motif
in Romanesque sculpture. Meant at an edifying purpose, sirens associated
with urban destruction, lust, and avarice, signify the menace of sin
they seduce humanity to fall into. The virtuous Christian, recognizing
the long-enduring classical motif in its new Christian context, should
take the paradigm of Odysseus in his Christological typology, and restrain
from evil. Though constituting a rather popular motif of Romanesque
sculpture in general, sirens seem to inhabit many of the churches of
the Auvergne and the Velay regions of France, thus forming a conspicuous
part of the local imagery. More than sheer enthusiasm for the antique,
as past scholarship would have it, sirens seem to have chanted a very
specific local chant in Aubergne-Velay. Constituting a major employed
motif which testifies to a profound understanding of their contextual
implications, they represent a multifaceted image denoting didactic,
apothropaic, liturgical, social, and political messages.
It is the purpose of this paper to uncover the versatile imports of
the siren antique motif in Romanesque Auvergne-Velay by pointing out
their meticulous, perplexing delineation. The first part of this paper
will survey the range of allegorical significances of sirens from Homer
to Jerome and to medieval exegeses, followed by a description of sirens
in Auvergne-Velay. Then I would like to suggest a new reading of the
particular rendering of sirens in the small church of Pont-du-Château
and in the pilgrimage church of Notre-Dame of Orcival, which may be
a local historical significance.
Dr. Caroline Igra (University of Haifa, Israel)
Servants to Patronage, Witnesses to Change: Italian Artists
Abroad and the Modern Cityscape
This study will offer three paradigms of the unusually
propitious relationship between cityscapist and patron which emerged
in the early modern period, and continued well into the nineteenth century,
developing side by side with the simultaneously developing cities themselves.
Antonio Canaletto’s ten year tenure in England, occupied as it
was with recording the vast physical changes to which London was then
subject, certainly set the stage for the work of future foreign artists.
His success inspired the later cityscape careers of Italian artists
Giuseppe Canella, as noted from his ten year career in Paris in the
1820s, and Giuseppe de Nittis, in his fifteen year residence in the
City of Light beginning in 1868.
Witness to periods of great physical change, these three Italian artists
were called upon to harness their abilities as cityscapists to the aspirations
of high-ranking patrons, monarchs and various official governing bodies.
They were required not only to document the physical uprooting to which
these cities and citizens were exposed but even more significantly,
to provide some kind of “revelatory” imagery. The hope of
their well-connected patrons was that such art would transcend its role
as documentation, and capture the spiritual hope for the bright future
to which those witnessing these urban projects aspired. Ideally, this
forward-looking imagery would justify those vast programs of destruction
and reconstruction to which urban metropolises - such as London and
Paris - were subjected in pursuit of the goals of modernization and
of meeting the needs of future generations.
Meital Itzkovich (University of Haifa, Israel)
Italian Influences in 16th Century Sevillian Painting: The
Example of Luis de Vargas
Seville in the sixteenth century regarded itself as the
"New Rome," a vision encouraged by the great wealth entering
the city from the Americas. This wealth prompted a large number of art
commissions in the various media, and the city attracted numerous Spanish
and foreign artists eager to be commissioned by an affluent patron.
A good many of these artists were painters influenced by Italian Mannerism,
directly or indirectly, and their works introduced Italianate features
to Sevillian painting of the mid-sixteenth century. One of the most
prominent and fascinating of these painters was Luis de Vargas.
Vargas, a Sevillian born painter (c. 1506-1567), spent a considerable
period of his life in Italy. There are various versions regarding the
dates of his stay there but according to recent studies it probably
took place between 1527-1534 and 1541-1549. In 1550 he is documented
back in Seville where he stayed and worked until his death. To his late
Sevillian period belong the few paintings by him known to us today,
and these attest to direct contact with the Mannerist painting in Rome
and Florence in the 1530's and 1540's, especially that of Perino del
Vaga, Giorgio Vasari and Francesco Salviati. This contact is best illustrated
in his paintings in the Seville Cathedral which combine Italian influences
with a Spanish touch.
Mr. Yossi
Klein (The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel)
Local Art versus Mediterranean Architecture
The proposed paper examine parallel expressions of local
artistic and architectural culture during the period of the "beginning
of the State" by comparing the art work of Aharon Kahana and the
architecture of his private house. This building, which has in the meantime
become a museum, is one of the first and finest creations of the architect
Yaacov Rechter.
The discussion lays bare the contradiction between
"modern" and "universal" values and the first attempts
at local rhetoric.
Dr. Katrin Kogman-Appel (Ben Gurion University of the Negev,
Israel)
Italy and Hebrew Manuscript Painting in Catalonia
The paper discusses Italian iconographic influences in
Catalan painting. Echoes of Italian art have been observed in the past
mainly in stylistic analysis and have been linked to the activity of
the workshop of Ferrer and Arnau Bassa. Iconographic influence from
Italy has been dealt with as an extension of this stylistic development.
The paper first makes a distinction between iconographic influence prior
to the Bassas and the latter's interest in Italian style. Second, it
illuminates the traces of Italian iconography against the background
of the cultural, political, and social history of the Jews in both Catalonia
and Italy and in terms of the Christian-Jewish cultural dialogue.
Dr. Diana Kottler (Beit-Berl College, Israel)
Eclecticism in the Art of Apulian Port Cities: the Case
of Monopoli
The paper will discuss monuments and works of art created in Monopoli
during the Middle Ages which display elements drawn from different places
in the Mediterranean as well as north of the Alps. Monopoli's active
seaport must have been instrumental in transmitting artistic influences
and in creating a local dialect which reveals international connections.
Dr. Shula Laderman (Bar-Ilan University, Israel) Biblical Cosmology
in Art and Liturgy of Early Christianity
The Apostolic Constitutions, is a Christian liturgical collection believed
to have been compiled in Syria in the fourth century based on Jewish
liturgical sources. The Christian Topography is an illuminated Byzantine
manuscript thought to have been written and illustrated by Constantine
of Antioch in the sixth century. Both works use a specific homiletic
approach, in order to present a cosmological typology that emphasizes
the connection between the act of Creation in the book of Genesis and
the structure of the wilderness Tabernacle in the book of Exodus. The
verses used by both works provide a concrete understanding of a schematic
model of the world whose origin is apparently in early Jewish Hellenistic
writings. The miniatures appearing in the extant copies of the illuminated
Christian Topography translate these biblical accounts into visual images
and create a pictorial blueprint of the structure of the world.
The proposed lecture aims to demonstrate that the liturgy of the Apostolic
Constitutions may well have been the avenue through which Jewish Hellenistic
biblical cosmological ideas were transferred to the author/illustrator
of the Christian Topography.
Prof. Alexei Lidov (Research Center for Eastern Christian Culture,
Moscow, Russia)
Mediterranean Hierotopy. Performances with Miraculous Icons
This paper is based on the concept of ‘Hierotopy’
(Ierotopia), meaning the creation of sacred spaces and the historical
research that defines this special form of human creativity. Hierotopy
spans the traditional fields of art history, archaeology, anthropology,
and religious studies. Each particular sacred space may be examined
as a new type of historical source which itself is a complex of various
arts and cultural activities. From this point of view, architectural
setting, pictorial decoration, music context, lighting or fragrance,
as well as numerous other rituals, might be considered as elements of
this complex structure, and subordinated to the major project of a particular
sacred space. The Hierotopic vision and approach may reveal a new layer
of subjects. It concerns iconic images created in space. The combination
of some images in a specific church, or one image in ritual context
could present another iconic image, not formally depicted on panels
or walls, but made implicit in a given sacred space between or around
the actual pictures. This presentation discusses ‘performances’
involving miraculous icons in the Hellenic world. A characteristic Byzantine
example is the Tuesday rite with the Hodegetria of Constantinople, which
was the most venerable ‘spatial icon’ in the East and the
West from the twelfth to fifteenth century. One might find the roots
of this phenomenon in the cult of miraculous images in Ancient Greece,
which presents similar approaches and archetypal structures. Furthermore,
some patterns of Ancient Greek and Byzantine traditions survived in
the religious practice of the modern period.
Prof. Ricardo de Mambro Santos (Università di Roma “La
Sapienza”, Italy)
Migrations of Memory: The Invention of Beauty in Karel van
Mander
This paper will propose a selective reading of some important
aspects of the Northern Art Tradition as it had been exposed in Karel
van Mander's Schilder-Boeck – "The Book of Painting"
– (published in Haarlem in 1604) in order to analyze its theoretic
structure, its specific hermeneutic strategies and its problematic connections
with Giorgio Vasari's Lives of the Most Illustrious Painters, Sculptors
and Architects, (first published in Florence in 1550 and widely changed
in 1568). In fact, the first part of the paper will be devoted to the
investigation of the different modalities through which the artistic
parameters established by the Italian Renaissance tradition had been
absorbed – and strategically modified – by the Dutch and
Flemish artists during the Cinquencento, with special attention to Van
Mander's method of translating some categories from the Naturalis Historia
by Pliny the Elder, such as "Beauty" and "Variety",
and also from the Vasarian pages, in order to understand Van Mander's
pluralistic conception of "Manner". For this reason, the second
part of the paper will analyze the ways by which the Mediterranean "Manner"
had been transmitted, assimilated and transformed in the works produced
by the two most representative Masters of the Netherlandish tradition:
Pieter Bruegel (1528-1569) and Hendrick Goltzius (1558-1617). The paper
will attempt to verify the centrality of the "mnemonic" paradigm
in Van Mander's Art Theory: a fascinating journey into a labyrinthine
artistic tradition from the mimetic aspirations of its Renaissance masters
to the metamorphic ambitions of the Mannerism painters.
Dr. Naomi Meiri-Dann (Tel Aviv University, Israel)
Twelfth Century North Italian Mosaic Pavements and Pilgrimage
to Rome and the Holy Land
Mosaic pavements were laid, between the end of the eleventh
and the beginning of the thirteenth century in many North Italian churches.
It seems that these works share a common and unique feature: they all
display man’s actual life on earth. The paper will examine these
mosaic pavements in relation to the geographic spread of the churches
in which they were laid, along the roads leading the pilgrims, as well
as the Crusaders, to Rome and/or the Holy Land. The intrinsic meaning
of the Christian’s way of life portrayed in these mosaics is intensified
by their presence along the actual road traveled by the believer who
experiences a physical as well as a spiritual journey.
Dr. Mati Meyer (The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel)
“The Window of Testimony”: A Sign of Physical
and Spiritual Conception
Based on the ancient motif of “the Woman at the
Window”, Middle Byzantine art has devised a new iconographic version,
“the Window of Testimony.” The new formula, which appears
primarily in illuminated manuscripts, represents biblical female figures
such as Sarah and Bathsheba framed by a window while making known their
forthcoming conception of Isaac and Salomon, respectively. The annunciation
alludes not only to the physical process of becoming pregnant, but also
serves, first and foremost, to sum up abstract popular ideas and beliefs
of post-iconoclastic Byzantine culture and society, one of them being
the humanity of Christ. This idea is mainly propagated through the theme
of the maternity of the Virgin. And, indeed, the visual rendering of
the female figures of the Bible framed by the window in Byzantine art
displays iconographic parallels with the image of Mary. Subsequently,
these biblical images serve to translate Christological and Marian themes
of conception into real signs that were easier to grasp by the wider
public.
Dr. Edina Meyer-Maril (Tel Aviv University, Israel)
The Flat Roof – Mediterranean, Oriental or Modern?
The paper will discuss the different interpretations of
the flat roof in Israeli architecture since the mid nineteenth century
until today, reflecting changing architectural concepts and cultural
identities.
Dr. Rachel Milstein (The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel)
Alexander the Great in a Muslim Garb
The story of Alexander the Great makes an integral part
of Islamic (mostly Persian) epics, which form and express the medieval
Islamic ideas of royalty. His biography, originally based on Greek sources,
was modified and enriched by Muslim authors to create an image of a
man of science and an avid seeker of eternal life, as well as a world
conqueror and a just ruler. Alexander was often depicted in miniature
illustrations of the "Book of Kings", Sufi metaphorical poesie,
accounts of the marvels of the world, and even eschatological texts.
My paper will present the many aspects of this composite image, its
sources, and the various aspects of Islamic civilizations that are manifest
through his illustrated adventures.
Prof. Alexander Nagel (University of Toronto, Canada)
A Statue of Christ from the Holy Land in Renaissance Italy
The period around 1500 saw the rise of a restricted but
conspicuous trend of all’antica statues of Jesus in bronze and
marble on the altars of churches in Italy. Free-standing statuary in
bronze or marble was a very rare sight in churches at this time, and
not only due to reasons of expense. The free-standing statue, especially
in valuable materials, was associated with pagan idolatry throughout
the Middle Ages. The most frequent visualization of the “idol”
throughout the medieval period was in the form of a statue in the round.
And yet in humanist culture all’antica statuary was also considered
one of the highest forms of art. To some artists and humanists it seemed
only appropriate to represent Jesus in the heroic form of a statue,
especially as Jesus himself lived in Roman antiquity. To some reformers,
the unitary form and idealizing rhetoric of the free-standing statue
also offered a welcome antidote to the over-elaboration and indeterminacies
of contemporary painting. And yet the form carried highly suspect, even
demonic associations.
This paper studies efforts undertaken in Italy to make the form “safe”
for Christian purposes. It will concentrate on one understudied bronze
statue of Jesus that created a sensation in Venice in the years around
1500, impelling such artists as Carpaccio, Cima da Conegliano, Alvise
Vivarini, and others to use it as a model in their own works. The paper
argues that the statue carried such authority because it was understood
as a version or iteration of a “first” bronze statue of
Jesus believed to have been made in the lifetime of Jesus, and famously
recorded by Eusebius in Caesarea, present-day Banyas. This statue thus
carried the authority of a “true likeness”—its all’antica
qualities were part of its claim to original status. We thus see a convergence
of a humanist culture that saw the forms of antiquity as a path to cultural
renewal and a reform-minded culture that aimed to return to the original,
pure forms of early Christianity. It thus allows us to consider more
famous works, such as Michelangelo’s Minerva Christ, in a new
light.
Prof. Attilio Petruccioli (University of Bari, Italy)
History, Structure and Landscape in the Mediterranean Region.
For some scholars landscape is a poetical emotion, for
others is an aesthetical experience connected to vision. I believe that
landscape (as architecture) is structure i.e. a system of elements hierarchically
ordered and in dialectic interdependent relationship.
The complexity of such system ( imagine a valley in a pre-industrial
moment with its settlements, routes, agricultural implants etc ) can
be interpreted only through the simplificative concept of type and its
transformation in time or typological process.
The reconstruction of the typological process is an unavoidable necessity
prior to any intervention of design on a given landscape.
In spite of the complex stratifications of civilizations that have transformed
its landscape, forms and uses, I believe that two main moments of this
process have create the Mediterranean character of our region: the first
phase of the formative cycle corresponding to the installations and
routes on the ridges and the fourth phase of the formative cycle corresponding
to the systematic formation of the large plains. The ridge phase with
its typical natural morphology is the real backbone of the landscape,
the plains phase with the geometric division of the land, the installation
of the Hellenistic and Roman modules and grids has left a network of
formal relations still readable in the present landscape.
Reading Italian and Middle Eastern landscapes with the methodological
tools of the Italian School of Saverio Muratori the paper discusses
the strong relationship between morphology of the land and form of the
landscape, in all its scalar components from territory, to settlement
to architecture.
Prof. Elisheva Revel-Neher (The Hebrew University of Jerusalem,
Israel)
The Voice, the Cloud, the Absence: Figurations of the Non-Figurable
in Jewish Art
Belief in the Unique, Invisible God is the essence of
Jewish philosophy and theology. In Jewish Art, the clash between figuration
and the purposeful prohibition of representation leads to various tentavives
of pictorial interpretation. From anthropomorphic details to visual
translations of the biblical text, this lecture will re-examine the
origins and development of the “non-figurations” of the
Divine in Jewish Art. It will focus on works of art, mainly mosaics
and illuminated manuscripts, from Eretz-Israel to Spain, between the
third and the thirteenth centuries. Comparisons will be drawn with Christian
and Moslem art.
Dr. Jochai Rosen (University of Haifa, Israel)
The "Classical Portrait": Another Facet of Classicism
in Early Modern Northern Europe
We are quite used to seeing early modern European portraits
of distinguished people depicted against the backdrop of a classical
column and a dramatic curtain. Perhaps the most striking example would
be Hyacinthe Rigaud's "Portrait of Louis XIV" (1701, o/c,
279 x 190 cm, Musée du Louvre, Paris). Some portraits include
a classical niche topped with a conch which might even include a statue;
others might depict the sitter accompanied by a classical bust or a
relief. The richness of the classical world was discovered in Northern
Europe during the Renaissance. The true or presumed knowledge of classical
culture soon became a status symbol and it is quite clear that these
portraits were meant to arouse a sense of the 'antique' and to present
the sitters as versed in the classical. In view of this classicism it
is not surprising to realize that most 'classical portraits' were painted
north of the Alps. Indeed some of the most important contributors to
the development of this type of a portrait into a leading formula in
European portraiture were northern European painters, among them Hans
Holbein, Rubens, Van Dyck and Reynolds. The purpose of this paper is
to examine the development and appeal of this portrait formula in Northern
Europe as an expression of the admiration of classical culture, especially
in comparison with similar portraits created by Italian contemporaries
such as Sebastiano del Piombo, Titian, Moroni, Batoni and others.
Dr. Victoria Sabetai
(Research Centre for Antiquity, Academy of Athens, Greece)
Nuptial
Imagery at the Age of Pericles: Attic Red-Figured Vases at the Benaki
Museum, Athens
The Benaki Museum
houses a collection of red-figured vases, some of which are associated
with nuptials through their vase-shape and iconography. In this paper
I present the vases themselves and discuss the visual language and iconographic
conventions of Attic wedding scenes. Although the established scheme
focuses on the emblematic depiction of the bridal couple, certain vase-painters
enrich the standard version with pictorial motifs referring to wifely
and manly ideals. The imagery concurs with the highly idealized Parthenoneian
art and reflects the importance of the marital union under the Classical
Democracy in Athens.
Prof. Wilhelm Schlink (Kunstgeschichtliches Institut
der Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg, Germany)
Jacob Burckhardt and the end of the nostalgia for Italy
in German art-history
In the beginning of his career as author and teacher Jacob
Burckhardt was a convinced exponent of the nostalgia for Italy, his
nostalgia was conceived by Winckelmann and his contemporaries in the
second half of eighteenth century. But when the older Burckhardt repeated
his lectures on 'newer art from 1550 on' in the 1780s he had lost his
heart rather to the Netherlandish Art of the seventeenth century. The
criterion of Italian Renaissance Art as a norm for the art of all times
was replaced by the democratic impulse of the northern genres (genera,
Gattungen). In late nineteenth century Burckhardt stood not alone with
this metamorphosis.
Dr. Ada V. Segre (University of Milan, Italy)
Messengers from Mount Carmel: the Carmelites and Sacred
Sites
Mount Carmel constitutes an interesting landscape, which
underwent a process of sanctification, and its image, both real or transfigured
through idealization, was replicated throughout the world by the Carmelite
Order. A similar and far better-known case is undoubtedly Jerusalem,
a fundamental presence in Western culture and art. Sacred sites on Mount
Carmel became the object of pilgrimage, mostly associated with the prophet/saint
Elijah (and to a minor extent Elisha), and to the Virgin Mary of the
Carmel. The sacralization of precise spots on Mount Carmel possibly
resulted from the combination of a natural scenery with distinctive
features, and the popularization of its image by the Carmelite Order.
This paper presents the locations on Mount Carmel which became associated
with Carmelite presence,comprising the areas of the "Cave of Elijah",
"Stella Maris", Wadi Siach, Ysfia, and the Mochraka. In addition
to attempting to trace their history, it explores the reasons which
led to the identification of precise sites with events narrated in the
Old and New Testament. Pre-existing traditions, the presence of religious
hermit communities, and those elements in the landscape which might
have been perceived as special are discussed here.
Echoes of Mount Carmel first as a lost religious landscape, then rediscovered
as such, are frequent in Western culture and art. The location of new
Carmelite settlements has always been guided, and still is, by the evocation
of the original Mount Carmel. In this view, Mount Carmel appears to
be subject to a process similar to Jerusalem in its transposition to
the Sacri Monti, replicas of the sacred city as the scene of the Passion
in the Alpine landscapes of northern Italy. This paper presents examples
of the transposition of Mount Carmel sacred landscape into Europe, and
tries to provide an evaluation of its influence as a cultural landscape.
Ms. Adi Shelach
Classical Motifs in Venetian Art: A Painting by Benedetto Diana
Due to her extensive marine trade in the Mediterranean
and to the direct contact with eastern cultures, Venice gradually became
a multi-cultural city, with a unique openness to Greek language and
tradition. Deprived of a classical past of their own, the Venetians
acquired, collected, documented and even plundered residuals of antiquity
and early Christianity, integrating them into the public sphere to shape
a self-identification of the city as a "Second Rome". During
the 15th century to the identity of the Stato da Mar was added
another identity, that of the Stato da Terraferma.
This paper will suggest a reading of the iconography of the Assumption
of the Virgin painted by Benedetto Diana in Crema, against this
cultural background. Crema's strategic significance at the western borders
of the Venetian territory can be recognized in the painting. Another
source of influence was the Hypnerotomachia Poliphili, published
in Venice in 1499. A temple of Venus Physizoa, minutely described in
this Antiquarian romance, supplied, as I will suggest, a source for
the architectural scenography of the painting. The hybrid language of
the book, combining Latin, Greek and the vernacular, might have influenced
Diana's style as well.
Mr. Guy Tal (Indiana University
at Bloomington)
Universal Language and the Overlooked Gestures of Melancholy
in Goya’s Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters
One of the cultural stereotypes that unites Mediterranean
inhabitants is blunt gesticulation during conversation. These gestures
either accentuate the emotional state of the speaker or amplify the
content by adding conventional signals for certain words or statements.
In that way, an Israeli tourist in Italy, for instance, may understand
and express mood and even content through gestures alone when conversing
with locals. Achievement of such communicative capability was exactly
the goal of eighteenth-century philosophers and humanists who endeavored
to canonize a universal language; that is, to globalize Europe by using
the single language of hand gestures.
In this paper I will demonstrate the Universal Language through Goya’s
most famous and intriguing print, The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters
(Capricho 43), which depicts the artist dreaming of fantastic apparitions,
and its two preparatory drawings. The second drawing bears the inscription
Ydioma universal (“Universal Language”), correctly interpreted
by some scholars as referring to the idea of gestural language. Quite
surprisingly, scholars did not correlate the inscription with its substantial
demonstration: the gestures made by the figure of the artist in the
images themselves.
Goya, whose interest in Universal Language was artistic as well as personal
due to his deafness, used instructional books about the “Language
of the Hand” as the basis for the gestures displayed in the three
versions of Capricho 43. Through comparisons with the illustrations
in these books I will identify these gestures as melancholic. Then,
by providing another possible source for the print, I will interpret
the artist’s melancholy as the stimulus of his fertile imagination.
Capricho 43 was originally intended to be the frontispiece of the Caprichos
series and, as such, it conveys one of Goya’s purposes in generating
this series: to proclaim, by depicting himself employing Universal Language,
that his art is universal and can be read by everyone.
Dr. Daniel M. Unger (Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Israel)
The Yearning for the Holy Land in Seventeenth-Century Pastoral
Depictions of Erminia and the Shepherds
In 1602, Giovanni Battista Agucchi, a senior official
in the papal court as well as a theoretician of art, wrote to the well-known
Bolognese painter Ludovico Carracci and asked him to paint the pastoral
scene of Erminia’s encounter with the old shepherd and his three
sons in the village on the banks of the Jordan River. The scene was
taken from Torquato Tasso’s Gerusalemme Liberata, a Virgilian
epos of a Christian crusade that ended with the conquest of Jerusalem
from the Saracenes. In his letter Agucchi gave a detailed account of
how the scene should be portrayed, stressing among others that the scenery
should resemble a Palestinian village near the Jordan River. In so doing
Agucchi went beyond Tasso’s text, which was rather obscure when
dealing with the description of the village and its surroundings. Agucchi’s
meticulous account specified the types of trees commonly found in these
parts of the Mediterranean, such as, olive, laurel, and palm trees,
insisting that they be incorporated in Ludovici’s rendering of
the village.
Ludovico delivered his painting, today part of the Real Palacio de la
Granaja collection at San Ildefonso, to Agucchi in 1603. Agucchi was
not happy with the results, as we learn from his complaints in a letter
addressed to Annibale, Ludovico’s younger cousin. Ludovico’s
version was the first of many depictions of this specific scene in the
seventeenth-century. See, for example, Domenichino’s or Guercino’s
paintings. In fact, this scene became more popular in artistic representations
than any of the great battles described in the epos.
In this paper I focus on the reasons why this scene became so popular
in seventeenth-century painting. I believe that the answer can be found
in the fact that the painting bore a political message relating to contemporary
events, such the opening up of the new world and the struggle against
heresy in Catholic Europe. I argue that Agucchi chose the scene that
[seemingly] represents Heaven on earth, in order to shift the attention
of Catholics from the new world back to where it all started –
the Holy Land.
Yael Young (The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel)
Girls Playing Auloi in the Hellenistic World
Terracotta figurines are among the ubiquitous uncovered
findings at archaeological sites. The lecture will focus on terracotta
figurines of the type that depicts a girl playing auloi. The starting
point of the lecture is an unpublished figurine of the Israel Museum
collection. The lecture will discuss the stylistic and iconographic
aspects of the type in general, and of the figurine in particular.
The comparison of the figurine with other statuettes that depict the
same subject, points to a broad-spectrum of artistic styles and to a
diversity of representations. We can identify local styles that stem
from working methods of certain ateliers. Thus, an attempt will be made
to point to possible connection between manufacturing centers.
The iconographic examination will consider both other visual representations
and literary sources. The archaeological contexts of the figurines will
be taken into account too. The lecture will end with a discussion of
their meaning, role and function.
|